How Do You Grow a Genuine LinkedIn Network Without Sending Generic Connection Requests?

If you read the Reddit post about growing a LinkedIn network from 200 to 4,000 connections in six months, the main point is honestly simple: LinkedIn works better when you treat it like a relationship platform, not a collection game. That idea sounds obvious, but a lot of people still approach networking like they are trying to hit a quota. They send dozens of random requests, copy and paste the same message, and then wonder why nothing turns into real conversations, engagement, or opportunities.

The advice in that post is useful because it focuses on something that actually matters: familiarity before connection. People are much more likely to accept your request, reply to your message, and engage with your content if they have already seen your name in a thoughtful way.

So if you are wondering whether this strategy really works, the short answer is yes. And if you are trying to build a network that feels warm, useful, and relevant, this is one of the best ways to do it.

Why generic LinkedIn growth usually fails

Let’s be real. A large network does not automatically mean a valuable network. You can have thousands of connections and still get very little engagement, very few replies, and almost no real business outcomes.

That usually happens when people focus too much on quantity and ignore context. Here are a few common problems with mass connection tactics:

• People do not recognize your name, so your request feels random.
• Your message looks templated, which reduces trust immediately.
• You build a cold audience, not a real community.
• Your future posts get ignored because there was never any real interaction to begin with.

LinkedIn itself has been clear about the value of meaningful interaction and profile relevance. If you want a better understanding of profile and networking best practices, LinkedIn’s own guidance is worth reviewing: LinkedIn Help.

What made the Reddit strategy work?

The Reddit post breaks the process into three practical ideas, and all of them support one bigger principle: start the relationship before you ask for the connection.

1. Comment first, connect later

This might be the most important part.

Instead of sending a request right away, the poster spent around 10 minutes a day leaving genuine comments on posts from people they wanted to know. Not generic comments. Not empty praise. Actual observations, follow-up thoughts, or useful additions.

Why does that work?

• It makes your name familiar.
• It shows that you understand their content or industry.
• It creates a low-pressure introduction.
• It increases the chance that your eventual request feels natural.

Think about it like this: if someone has seen you leave helpful comments a few times, your request is no longer coming from a stranger. It is coming from “that person who always says something thoughtful.” That changes everything.

2. Use a specific connection request

Once there is a little familiarity, the next step is sending a short, specific note. The post gave a great example: reference the actual topic you discussed and keep it brief.

That matters because specificity signals effort. It tells the other person:

• I know who you are.
• I am not pasting this to 100 people.
• I am connecting for a real reason.

A good note might look like this:

• “Enjoyed your post on founder-led content. Your point about consistency was spot on. Would love to stay connected.”
• “Really liked our exchange on your hiring post. You raised a good point about candidate experience. Happy to connect.”
• “Your comments on B2B lead generation were useful. I’ve been testing something similar. Would be great to connect.”

Short works. Specific works. Overexplaining usually does not.

3. Focus on warm connections, not vanity metrics

This is the part a lot of people skip. A network is only useful if the people in it actually know, trust, or remember you.

That means 500 warm connections can absolutely outperform 5,000 random ones. Warm connections are more likely to:

• Reply to your posts
• Answer your messages
• Refer you to other people
• Think of you when opportunities come up
• Trust your expertise over time

So yes, growing from 200 to 4,000 is impressive. But the deeper lesson is not the number. It is the quality of the interactions that created that number.

How can you apply this on LinkedIn today?

If you want to try this approach yourself, here is a simple breakdown that keeps things manageable.

A practical 15-minute daily routine

• 5 minutes: Identify 5 to 10 people in your niche, industry, or target audience.
• 5 minutes: Leave 2 to 4 thoughtful comments on recent posts.
• 3 minutes: Reply to anyone who engaged with your own content.
• 2 minutes: Send 1 to 3 personalized connection requests to people you have already interacted with.

That is it. Nothing flashy. Just consistency.

Questions to ask before sending a request

If you are not sure whether to connect with someone yet, ask yourself:

• Have they seen my name before?
• Have I engaged with their content in a real way?
• Can I mention a specific post, conversation, or shared interest?
• Would this connection make sense for both of us?

If the answer is yes to most of those, your request is probably in a good place.

What does a “good comment” on LinkedIn actually look like?

This is where many people struggle. They hear “leave meaningful comments,” but they are not sure what that means in practice.

A strong LinkedIn comment usually does one of these:

• Adds a new angle
• Asks a useful follow-up question
• Shares a relevant experience
• Builds on the original point without trying to hijack the post

Examples:

• “This is a good point. I’ve noticed the same issue with cold outreach, especially when the message lacks context. Personalization takes more time, but the response quality is much better.”
• “Interesting take. Do you think this works better for founders than in-house marketers, or have you seen both respond similarly?”
• “Agreed on the trust factor. We’ve seen content engagement improve when the same people interact before any direct outreach happens.”

If you want more perspective on how engagement and thoughtful networking work on LinkedIn, this HubSpot article is helpful: HubSpot’s LinkedIn marketing guide.

What should you avoid?

There are a few habits that quietly damage your networking efforts:

• Sending requests immediately after viewing a profile with no context
• Using sales language too early
• Leaving one-word comments like “Nice” or “Great post”
• Trying to impress instead of connect
• Automating everything until your presence feels robotic

People can tell when the interaction is performative. You do not need to sound perfect. You just need to sound real.

Does this work for creators, job seekers, founders, and agencies?

Yes, but the way you apply it may look slightly different.

• Job seekers: Comment on recruiters, hiring managers, and professionals in your field before sending a request.
• Founders: Engage with investors, peers, industry voices, and potential partners by speaking to shared challenges.
• Creators: Build familiarity with people whose audiences overlap with yours.
• Agencies and consultants: Use comments to show thinking, not pitch services.

The core idea stays the same: build recognition first, then connection, then conversation.

If you want a broader view of relationship-building in professional settings, Harvard Business Review has useful reading on networking with more intention: HBR on networking.

So what is the real takeaway from the Reddit post?

The best part of the original post is that it pushes back against shallow growth tactics. It reminds people that LinkedIn is still human. People respond to familiarity, relevance, and sincerity more than scale.

If you are trying to grow your LinkedIn network, a better question is not just “How many people can I add?” but also:

• Who do I actually want to know?
• How can I show up in a way that feels useful?
• Would this person recognize my name if I sent a request today?
• Am I building an audience, or am I building trust?

That shift in mindset is usually what leads to better acceptance rates, better conversations, and better long-term results.

Final thought

If LinkedIn networking has felt awkward, forced, or ineffective, this approach is a good reset. Comment with intention. Connect with context. Think relationships before reach. It is slower than blasting out generic requests, but it usually works better.

Write better LinkedIn content with EXEED AI

EXEED AI is an AI tool that helps you ideate, draft, and schedule content for your LinkedIn. Turn raw ideas into polished posts and stay consistent without the guesswork. Try EXEED AI.